DAY 17 AND WAR IS HELL -- NO HEADLINES *THERE*
We've lost more personnel to training exercises, "friendly fire" and non-combative maneuvers (helicopter crashes not caused by hostile fire, etc.) than actual combat ... so far. That ratio won't hold if Iraqi soldiers continue to accept suicide missions. Why? Because that's one element of warfare Americans have never been able to wrap their brains around. It surprised us at Pearl Harbor, blind-sided us on 9/11 and I imagine it will continue to plague our "liberation" (occupation) of Iraq, just as it does Israelis from the PLO. Ironic, isn't it, that quadrillions of dollars, untold technological research & development, our highly trained soldiers and the masterminded combat implementation strategies of all our armed service divisions combined can be rendered so galactically impotent by such a low-tech opponent.
This war is unique in many ways. It's also remeniscent of the oldest wars in history.
It's the first global news event for which CNN has not been the exclusive live feed. FoxNews, CNBC, MSNBC, the BBC and all three American broadcast networks have "embedded reporters" travelling with coalition forces, dug into trenches five feet from the front lines and filing stories from every military installation used by the coalition. Does this mean we're getting objective, factual, accurate information in real time? No. It means we're getting filtered, anti-septic coverage of troop movements and maneuvers as well as impressive footage of successful assaults with an emphasis on technological superiority over the opposition. The same technology which brings us realtime reporting on multiple networks *FROM* the gulf region is delivering it back *TO* the gulf region.
"We aint seein nuthin' we don't want the Iraquis to know about and we's seein plenty our government wants the Iraquis to believe"
One would presume the press' positioning could furnish viewers a refreshing, less-biased alternative to the daily Pentagon and White House press conference reportings of coalition progress. Truthfully, we're seeing exactly what the Pentagon and the White House want us --and, more importantly at times-- the Iraqi government to see. The American and British press, though not limited to the exact language contained in whatever spews from the press core teletypes, are very restricted in terms of the information they report. The timeframes associated with the field reports are also skewed by design.
Correspondents travelling with troops must tape their reports against a backdrop non-indicative of their geographic location. If that locale is experiencing unique weather conditions (ex: a rain storm passing through a particular region of Iraq) reports from that armed services division (and those correspondents) are suspended. This policy exists to preserve the ambiguity of ground troops' distance from Baghdad and other Republican Guard defense bases.
The ground reporters are forbidden to discuss any coalition casualties on camera until after the Pentagon has cleared the story. Here again, one would BELIEVE this policy to be rooted in good faith; that the military wished to appropriately notify family members when a loved one dies, goes missing or is taken prisoner. Consistently, family members prove that media sources furnish more information, more quickly than Pentagon or DOD channels. The wife of one helicopter pilot deduced her husband had either been killed or captured by Iraqi forces from a "film at eleven" - type trailer. You see, pilots paint their wives' names on the undersides of aircraft they fly. Footage of the downed plane proudly furnished by Iraqi-TV gave form to her worst fears.
The few Western journalists based inside Baghdad are obligated by that government to dine on spoon-fed horse pockey. Between the manipulations of U.S. and Iraqi governments, fabrications of real time white truth pipelines from Baghdad to the living rooms of a global audience are impossible. Reporters are led each day by representatives of Iraq's Information Ministry to view specific damage. The guided tours showcase destruction to non-military targets such as schools, hospitals, and other civillian spaces. Dead bodies and people hospitalized with serious injuries are another area of emphasis. Conspicuously absent from said presentations is availability/access to military, communications or government sites --damaged or not. Iraqi civillian and military casualty figures are dubiously furnished by the Information Ministry. Fanning the flames of suspicion are Iraqi refusals to permit international Red Cross representatives to triage wounded civillians or visit "understaffed" hospitals which the Iraqi press insists are operating well above capacity.
Coverage of "Operation Iraqi Freedom" is still fascinating on its own level. For the first time in "recorded history" Western journalism is recording history in a brand-new locale and timeframe. The different mass media
Full-time news networks (CNN & FoxNews) are burdened, quite obviously, with the necessity to "keep it fresh" so their coverage is extensive to a fault. Beyond sharing whatever facts have been approved, these channels use commentary, interactive viewer participation, expert analysis and extensive debate as the journalistic equivalent of Hamburger Helper. The networks, by contrast, are sticking to a "distill and deliver" approach.
The value of war coverage found inside your daily newspaper should not be discounted despite the temptation to write this source off as "too little too late." This would be a mistake. Those admitting to spending any more than an hour before dinner
or just before bed catching up on the war officially waive their rights to use the expression "too little" with a straight face. "Too late" accurately describes any curiosity satisfied by reading YESTERDAY'S newspaper while "too far gone to absorb ideas or impressions" begins to explain the pitiful dynamic of reading anything older. You'll never understand war. Don't frustrate yourself with further attempts.
Today's paper (No names. The initials NYT, WSJ, CST, LAT and DMN leap to mind.) is an invaluable tool for satisfying normal to high degrees of reporting skepticism. I will not begin to defend the age of its headline. This will be something you first memorized as many as 18 hours ago. It may have been reported by ABC, obscured by the BBC, skipped by FoxNews, and debated on CNN (ergo, your skepticism. Welcome to America!) Unlike television recitations delivered "now, baby, now!" or "promptly at 11:00 following words from your local sponsor," newspaper reports are written, re-written, then proofread for glaring grammatical and historical boo-boos. From there a labor-intensive distribution is engaged which terminates on a nearby roof or rosebush. Minus the final segments of this process, the collective talent and intelligence are worth the wait. After a few short days, you'll associate daily feature articles with a comprehensive understanding from which there is no regression. To illustrate this evolvement, let's deconstruct the morning's top story.
THE ITEM: Pfc Jessica Lynch Rescued by Army Special Forces
THE BACKSTORY: 19-year-old Private First Class (Pfc) Jessica Lynch has been successfully rescued, after eight days of being listed as Missing In Action. She and seven other members of the 507th maintenance unit were ambushed when their convoy encountered Iraqi troops at an undisclosed location.
THE DOTS: Following a "dramatic," "heroic" rescue mission, Jessica was placed onto a stretcher and into a waiting black hawk helicopter which flew her to safety. American/British doctors who treated her en route listed her condition as "stable." She has two broken legs, a broken arm and is being treated for multiple gunshot wounds. She was found alone. In a hospital. Special forces including Army Rangers, Air Force pilots, combat controllers and Navy Seals raided Saddam Hospital pursuant to a tip from an Iraqi civillian that an American was inside.
THE HOOKS: Jessica is from Palestine, West Virginia, a town with a population of less than 1,000. A phonecall from an ambiguous U.S. Military administration source was initially believed by Jessica's father to be a "cruel April fool's joke." (My April Fool's joke was an Israeli headline: "U.S. Special Forces Rescue Palestinian Soldier") Jessica's hometown --and all of it-- was griefstricken by the tragic news from Jessica's unit and prayed regularly for Jessica's safe return along with the seven other missing soldiers that were with her. After a while, Jessica's father was able to be convinced that the news he received was genuine. The town lost it. It's hard not to be touched by the images of the city's fire truck driving back and forth through town, siren blazing, the driver yelling into a megaphone, "They've found Jessica! She's alive and safe!"
As this conflict has gone, it's been difficult to "scoop" the competition. Everyone covering the game has seats on the 50-yard line... under the watchful eyes of the referees. Why? Quite simply, the crystal in the chandeliers remains morally out of reach. Sure, it would be fascinating to observe this conflict with even a teensy bit of insight as to the strategies at play; kind of like watching two master chess players through a camera mounted above the playing board.
Ultimately our fascination with it all is tightly woven with varying degrees of patriotism, and a default respect for the soldiers who --if circumstances were different-- would go to battle against a more threatening enemy to preserve our way of life, our homes, and everything we find praiseworthy. Two notorious (by now) attempts to
With that in mind, being an "armchair general" ('sofa sargeant,' or whatever) also requires that a certain filtration standard exist. Yes, we're being extremely careful to not let any "battle secrets" fall into the wrong hands --because Iraqis have identical images coming into their living rooms-- but that persisting awareness works both ways. A percentage of the "coverage" we witness is manufactured without you and I --or any other Americans-- as members of the target audience. Glaringly obvious evidence of media manipulation has come daily in the form of Bush's coalition rhetoric. You know the speech I'm referring to. It's had more live performances than South Pacific and enjoyed as many television re-runs as "Gilligan's Island" and "I Love Lucy" combined. (With additional similarity in its shameless use of inserting audience reactions where they're perceived to belong.) Dyed-in-the-wool Republicans are even growing weary of these Presidential remarks. Any list of reassurrance the American people desire from the Commander in Chief at present begins and ends with some indication as to the expected brevity of this conflict (possible substitute: closure to the open-ended nature of U.S. involvement in schedule format.) Lacking either, protocol --if not career politician survival instincts-- scream for silence. Twelve repetitions of "as long as it takes to liberate the Iraqi people, eliminate Iraq's weapons of mass destruction and end the regime of Saddam Hussein" go beyond ignoring the needs of Bush's constituency by vocalizing exactly what nobody wants to hear. It's bad form; political "chicken" and completely out of character, even for Dub-yah. It's also irritating as hell.
IRAQI INFORMATION MINISTRY - Apparently, the representative we see on Al-Jazeera TV is thought of --even locally-- as a giant bufoon. He doesn't speak the Iraqi language very well.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment