Monday, September 24, 2007

REVIEW: “THE NEW ADVENTURES OF OLD CHRISTINE”

Julia Louis-Dreyfus fans will be ecstatic to learn Dreyfus has successfully broken 'The Seinfeld Curse.' The less fanatic, however, will likely catch a few episodes then wonder exactly how or where the appeal of …OLD CHRISTINE exists for us.

'The Seinfeld Curse,' for those who haven't noticed, seemingly rendered the hit show's cast members unable to successfully <>. Despite determined endeavors by A-List writers and producers, <>, Michael <>, <> and Dreyfus herself have failed to initiate voyages beyond a place where they've all been before: a post-Seinfeld primetime backyard to play in. Until now, that is...

Julia Louis-Dreyfus, uber-famous as SEINFELD's ‘Elaine,’ has recently added ‘Old Christine’ to her primetime character resume. She plays the title character in CBS' mid-season pickup THE NEW ADVENTURES OF OLD CHRISTINE, a comedy about the divorced mother of one juvenile--slash--landlord to her over-aged juvenile brother--slash--women's gym owner--slash—single, thirty-something female hell-bent on upgrading her marital status, despite the attention other aspects of her character subtract from her ability to do any of that very successfully.

The character ‘New Christine’ clearly has a lot on her plate. This extreme quantity also subtracts from the presence of sub-plots and the usual development of other (supporting) characters. The result is twenty-some-odd minutes all about a chief which boldly ignores the importance of Indians in a tribal setting. NEW CHRISTINE reeks of a monologue interrupted by the occasional cameo appearances of familiar faces to yell at, bitch about, ask hypothetical questions of, or whose advice gets listened to (then ignored) when problem solving alone generates too much to handle. Nobody exists on camera unless they serve the literary or technical needs of ‘Chief New Christine,’ whose presence will quickly become too much for sitcom audiences to handle.

Dreyfus fan club members surely applaud Julia's departure from ensembleism onto the very top rung of her own monarchy. As a SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE and SEINFELD cast member, her experience as a wide-ranged, talented comic actor would suggest a leading role to be popularity-plausible and a ratings-rewarding transfer within network TV. She has so much to bring to a leading character and has waited a long time to be given that chance. But unless you're jaundiced for Julia, you just find yourself wishing the scripts didn't bring so much of that leading character to us, week after week after week. She is in EVERY SCENE; ‘New Christine’ IS every scene.

THE NEW ADVENTURES... needs the newness of other characters and additional plotlines; ones which can be scripted with Louis-Dreyfus somewhere off-camera, spending a rogue scene or two learning those long, memorable, show-stealing monologues which she delivers so well. To be the show’s focus, it is not incumbent upon one actor to carry the show. One need only look at REBA, THE GILMORE GIRLS or WILL & GRACE to see that successful shows not only do not require the title character's inescapable on-camera presence but can ostensibly grow without it. Dreyfus is good as ‘Christine’ but the show would be better without as much ‘Christine.’

A de facto untapped and competent source of potential laughter is Dreyfus' TV business associate, played by the incessantly uproarious Wanda Sykes. Just imagining Sykes at the front desk of a ladies gym filled with obese women unsuccessfully attempting yoga, the Stairmaster and jazzercise... Do we need 'New Christine' to hilariously pull this off? No. Sykes could no doubt occasionally be trusted to keep the laughs coming.

It is difficult to determine what the rest of the regular cast (played by totally unknown actors) is capable of. They've not been given the opportunity to do anything except garnish Julia's presence, set her up to deliver punch lines or react to ‘Old Christine’'s dilemmas. Equally difficult to establish are the reasons ‘Old Christine’’s marriage fell apart. So far, the portrayal of her ex comes across as a man ‘Old Christine’ could have been married to just as much as someone she could still be married to. Aside from being taller, blonde and younger, we also can’t appreciate ‘New Christine’ as an understandable replacement in this not-altogether-objectionable man’s life.

And what of ‘New Christine?’ The show's title suggests a viewpoint that never becomes implicit; that of the ex-husband whose new girlfriend is also named Christine (get it?) We occasionally see ‘Old Christine’'s ex-hubby, the only character with a reason to make that distinction. He never does. The title also suggests more adventure than we’re ultimately privy to. Scenes featuring ‘New Christine’ are rarer still. For supposedly-obvious reasons, the two Christines don't get along so our understanding of this absence must be assumed.

Sometime before the winter of '06, another absence which must be assumed will be THE NEW ADVENTURES OF OLD CHRISTINE from CBS' fall schedule. Up to now the show's success can be principally attributed to three things: location, location and location. Nestled within the CBS 8pm-10pm hit comedy line-up which precedes the network's proven mega-hit CIS: MIAMI, …OLD CHRISTINE works as a placeholder. Its competition is essentially the second half-hours of 60-minute shows on other networks and its lead-in is CBS’ popular TWO AND A HALF MEN. Color bars would probably garner two-thirds of those ratings! Yet if moved to a more vulnerable time slot without major changes, CHRISTINE’s death is certain.

No comments: