Monday, September 24, 2007

TO: THE EDITOR, SAN FRANCISCO WEEKLY

RE: TWU250A LETTER PUBLISHED IN YOUR JULY 2-8, 2003 ISSUE

Pasts can be effortful things. They are, as you confessed, a primary source of self-definition, explaining
much --if not all-- the behavior which is ultimately responsible (to blame?) for whomever it is we are
presently. Remember, my friend, that any past is capable of playing a completely antihetic role, going
forward. What you do tomorrow (and why you do it) don't require a profound connection to today or
yesterday. We all realize it's colossally impractical to disavow the cogencies we have with our pasts and the
pasts of others because that's always going to be a part of us. On the other hand, a profound frame of
reference in/to the past should be safeguarded; reserved for biographical, story-telling and learning
experiences. Your apologue potentially qualifies on all three fronts.

We have never met. Yet I confess to forming a mental picture of you quite similar to the charactiture you
chastised two independently-researched articles for "inaccurately" compiling. Okay, perhaps both women
exercised journalistic license by taking the same low road and your (former) character came off to the
stereotypical side of an image you have no experience shaking off. I'm still with you, brother. But a "pimp"
is a stereotype; one I hope you find joy associating with your past and not your present. On the plus side,
pimps have people skills cultivated to a level beyond the training most career customer service-types ever
receive. It's not all bad.

Regardless of how your employment situation resolves itself (assuming there are still cards to play in this
unfamiliar extension of "the game,") your story is a compelling one. It's clear to me you've done the math
and realized there's some mileage potential inherent to any ole' fashioned "American Dream" story --perhaps
exponentially more so given that your protagonist is African-American. At face value, I'm quite inclined to
agree with you. Any departure from the lifestyle whose tawdry allure held you captive (and continues to
imprison many others, no doubt) is a story worth telling, given a proper context. The fact that the last pages
of your story include a tenure as the vice president of *ANYTHING* have me believing the pages in between
contain a narrative I would encourage my son to read, if I don't read it to him myself.

I'm compelled to take issue with the inconsistency to some of the conclusions you have drawn. Either our
"omnificient and omnipresent creator has bountifully blessed you beyond belief" or "there is no forgiveness,
and no paradise to be found in mainstream America for former participants of the lifestyle known as the
Game." You simply cannot purport both as truth. Eleven years with the TWU250A would seem to indicate
that redemption was yours. The story, as you've recounted it, leaves that elephant in the living room of this
reader and perhaps a number of others.

Perhaps the over-bosses of the TWU250A have become inappropriately re-focused. Or, as you accuse,
perhaps they never had it at all. You need to search your soul and decide which statement is true. Know that
there will be unattractive repercussions to either conclusion. If in fact an organized "witch hunt" did take
place, you must realize (as I think you have) that you furnished the hunted --pointed black hat, broom and
all-- to the hunters. On the other hand, if the posse of which you speak is truly mission-less, given to random
acts of persecution without notice or the courtesy of a fair trial, a valid conclusion to draw would be one that
indicates you were wasting your time aspiring to climb any ladders within such ranks. I don't know why an
eleven year record couldn't stand on its own --especially in a union environment. I suspect therein lies
perhaps the biggest lesson to be drawn from all of this.

You're very quick to play the First Amendment constitutional and Title 7 cards. It is unarguably your right to
do so at any juncture of your life as a United States Citizen. Unfortunately, in the game of employment, your
superiors can trump those moves with Employment at Will legislation I'm sure you're familiar with. You can
be fired from almost any job, at any time, by any employer, with or without a reason. The grand irony here
is that you are supposedly protected by the very union you have served so diligently these past years. For
undisclosed reasons, the system has failed you and that's an injustice you should be preoccupied with
illuminating.

Among the many truly awesome benefits within that Trojan horse called the First Amendment is an implied
hope that self-censorship will prevail, thereby limiting the distances First Amendment rights actually travel.
It's hopeless to legislate decorum, propriety, appropriateness and context. The final judgement will always
find in favor of the greater freedom, which is to interpret --or entirely circumvent-- these filters. And doing
so does not happen without consequence. I'm glad I live in a country which protects her citizens' rights to
disclose anything about themselves, anything they believe; any opinion they have. I correspond with quite
a few people who don't and when I truly begin to believe my life probably couldn't be any more miserable,
I need only recall a few passages from the Declaration of Independence, our wonderful Constitution or the
Bill of Rights. It's easy to forget them, the blood shed by those who fought for them and the corresponding
responsibility we have as individuals empowered with these rights.

When my older brother told my father he was gay, he was absolutely within his rights to do so. Within the
months which followed, he told quite a few people, making a point of mentioning it in many situations it would
otherwise never have come up. It empowered him; perhaps to a greater extent because he had just returned
from two years of foreign service in a country whose laws favor any father who kills his son following a
similar conversation. On our shores, self-disclosure is not a crime. Neither is being homosexual. You cannot
be punished for making people aware of who you are or were, even if it annoys them. The law is on your
side. What my brother didn't realize is that many of those he had this conversation with --including his [our]
own father-- never breathed the same air around him again. Even though the only fundamental thing that
changed was other people's information, he was responsible for creating a different dynamic between them.
There was doubt. There were situations from the past which played out differently in the present. There were
new erosions to what had been solid understandings and relationship foundations. The few external benefits
derived from his disclosures such as newfound respect and broader understandings of his personal
experience didn't manifest themselves immediately and were far outnumbered by experiences which
ultimately played out to negative conclusions. It became easier for some to argue with him. Still others chose
not to deal with him anymore at all.

Perhaps the comparison strikes you as a gross oversimplification of recent events in your life. I can't imagine
the impact either disclosure would have on the life I currently enjoy so it's possible I'm making an equasion
where I shouldn't. Be that as it may (and without discounting the value embracing your past at this time in
your life may bring) the only hope my writing this carries is that you take a solid inventory of the impact
publicly "marrying" your past to your present has had --and could have, going forward. Forgive my crass
curiosity but how much true happiness could a husband-father-novelist-film maker-music-producer truly lose
when a public transportation administrator's responsibilities are removed from such a dynamic, creative
future? (It's the paycheck, isn't it?)

Paradise is a world that celebrates diversification from "the mainstream" and thrives on the experiences all
of God's children have to contribute to the betterment of that world. This is what change looks like, my
brother. It sucks at first and it can be as difficult to embrace as a troubled past. But I think you know as soon
as that becomes possible, you'll see opportunities for what they are and those who've declined to be a part
of your future for what they are.

Good luck and God bless!

No comments: